Advantages of Low-carbon Indoor Farming on the Environment.

Environmental Business Review | Friday, September 02, 2022

A new study questions the universal land-saving demands of vertical farming, finding that there is no one-size-fits-all approach for land use, food security, and sustainable agriculture.

FREMONT, CA: Controlled Environment Agriculture (CEA) is gaining fame due to population increase, environmental change, and growing concerns about food security and sustainability. Relating to growing space, commercial greenhouses and vertical farms promise a higher crop yield from locally obtained materials than open-field agricultural methods. Researchers analyzed the potential crop output of six vegetables (selected for nutritional content and suitability for CEA farming) concerning growing space in a report published in Nature Food.

The inclusion of extra acreage utilized by wind and solar farms to harvest low-carbon energy in the total "expanding space" estimates were crucial to the study. Vertical farms and commercial greenhouses are land-saving sustainable farming, although these farming systems rely heavily on power to keep crops growing in a healthy climate. A low-carbon power supply must back up this demand to be sustainable. The space needed to captivate renewable energy must be included in the overall land footprint to adequately analyze the sustainability and footprint of each agricultural practice. The researchers assessed vertical farms, greenhouses, and open-field farming in nine city areas: Reykjavik, Stockholm, Boston, Tokyo, Santiago, Johannesburg, Phoenix, Singapore, and the United Arab Emirates, all of which had different land availability, meteorological conditions, and population density. When analyzing the total land required to cultivate the six vegetables, the results revealed that location was the deciding factor. Greenhouses and vertical farms could minimize the net land footprint (combined land use per capita) compared to open-field farming in colder climes. Open-field agriculture had a smaller land footprint than vertical farms in warmer climes. Despite energy use being very location-dependent, greenhouses had the smallest land footprint of the three produce-growing systems in most regions modeled—not just the temperate, less seasonal ones. Energy demand fluctuations resulted in a higher cost per energy unit, especially in colder places where the onshore wind was the primary renewable. However, commercial greenhouses had a lower energy demand per food unit. The researchers also conducted local geographical assessments of available farmland and land appropriate for energy generation in each area to decide where land could be reused, yielding exciting results. The aggregate land footprint of vertical indoor and open-field farming methods in Stockholm was similar. Still, there is more arable farmland in the area, and land fit for wind energy generation is relatively scarce, casting doubt on the viability of CEA farming in the absence of alternative low-carbon energy sources.

Stay ahead of the industry with exclusive feature stories on the top companies, expert insights and the latest news delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe today.

More in News

Technology has become indispensable for enhancing the accuracy, efficiency, and sustainability of environmental consulting. As ecological challenges grow more complex—from climate change and pollution to resource management and regulatory compliance—consultants are turning to advanced technologies to analyze data, assess risks, and recommend actionable strategies. These digital solutions transform the way consultants engage with natural environments, offering vital insights to support both ecological preservation and economic development. Remote Sensing and Geographic Information Systems Remote sensing and Geographic Information Systems (GIS) are at the forefront of environmental data collection and analysis. These technologies enable consultants to monitor landscapes, vegetation patterns, and water resources remotely, often using satellite imagery or drone-mounted sensors. By combining remotely sensed data with GIS mapping, consultants can produce detailed visualizations of ecosystems, track changes over time, and model the potential environmental impacts of proposed developments. This spatial data is essential for habitat assessments, land use planning, and environmental impact studies, allowing for more informed decision-making based on real-world observations. Real-Time Monitoring and Data Collection Tools Environmental consulting increasingly relies on real-time monitoring systems to gather continuous data on air quality, water conditions, soil contamination, and other environmental factors. These systems often include sensor networks deployed in the field, which automatically transmit data to centralized platforms for analysis. Using Internet of Things (IoT) technologies, consultants can detect environmental changes as they happen, enabling early intervention and faster response to potential threats. For example, water sensors can alert teams to chemical spills or changes in pH levels, while air monitors can track particulate matter in urban or industrial areas. This constant flow of information supports more proactive environmental management strategies. Modeling Software and Predictive Analytics Advanced modeling software and predictive analytics tools allow environmental consultants to simulate various scenarios and forecast potential outcomes. Whether evaluating the impact of a construction project on a nearby wetland or assessing long-term climate risks to a coastal region, these tools help predict changes and guide mitigation efforts. Using machine learning and artificial intelligence enhances the ability to identify patterns in large data sets, offering deeper insights and improving the accuracy of environmental forecasts. These technologies also aid in regulatory compliance, helping organizations anticipate and meet ecological standards more efficiently. Integrating technology into environmental consulting improves the quality and speed of assessments and promotes greater transparency and collaboration. Digital platforms allow stakeholders—clients, regulators, and the public—to access environmental data, review project outcomes, and participate in sustainable planning. As environmental concerns continue to grow, the role of technology will only become more critical, empowering consultants to protect natural resources, support responsible development, and build a more sustainable future for all. ...Read more
Natural disasters, such as hurricanes, wildfires, droughts, and floods, are becoming more frequent and intense, causing significant harm to ecosystems and humans, which makes it even more urgent to address climate change. Hurricanes and Cyclones:  Hurricanes and cyclones, fueled by warming ocean temperatures, have become more frequent and intense in a changing climate. These storms bring destructive winds, storm surges, and torrential rainfall, causing widespread damage to coastal areas and infrastructure. Superstorms like Hurricane Katrina and Cyclone Idai are stark reminders of the catastrophic impact of extreme weather events exacerbated by climate change. Wildfires:  Prolonged dry spells and increasing temperatures create ideal conditions for wildfires to ignite and rapidly spread. From the Australian outback to the Amazon jungle, wildfires have devastated vast tracts of land, destroying homes, forests, and wildlife habitats. Since these fires are unprecedented and ferocity, swift action is needed to mitigate climate change and manage ecosystems sustainably. Floods:  As temperatures rise, so does the risk of intense rainfall events and flooding. Urbanization and inadequate infrastructure exacerbate the impact of floods, leading to property damage, displacement, and loss of life. Floods devastate communities and strain resources and infrastructure, underscoring the importance of climate-resilient urban planning and flood management strategies. Droughts:  Prolonged droughts, exacerbated by climate change, have far-reaching consequences for agriculture, water security, and ecosystems. Regions reliant on rainfall for agriculture face crop failures, food shortages, and economic instability during periods of drought. Additionally, dwindling water supplies exacerbate conflicts over water resources, highlighting the interconnectedness of climate change and geopolitical tensions. Heatwaves:  Heatwaves are fueled by rising temperatures linked to climate change, which poses significant health hazards and strains energy infrastructure. The elderly and underprivileged groups are among the vulnerable groups most vulnerable to heat-related diseases and deaths. Additionally, heatwaves intensify the impacts of urban heat islands, making densely populated places more susceptible to heat stress. Melting Ice Caps and Sea-Level Rise:  Sea levels rise as polar ice caps and glaciers melt more quickly, endangering coastal ecosystems and livelihoods. Sea-level rise exacerbates storm surges, flooding, and erosion, resulting in coastal inundation and saltwater leaking into freshwater sources. In addition to upsetting global weather patterns, ice caps melting further destabilizes ecosystems and exacerbates climate extremes. Landslides and Soil Erosion:  Intense rainfall events and destabilized landscapes increase the risk of landslides and soil erosion, particularly in mountainous regions and areas prone to deforestation. Landslides pose significant hazards to communities, infrastructure, and transportation networks, necessitating proactive land management and erosion control measures to mitigate risks and protect vulnerable populations. ...Read more
Asbestos, once valued for its fire resistance and durability, is now recognized as a serious health hazard. When disturbed, it can release airborne fibers that, if inhaled, may lead to severe illnesses such as mesothelioma, lung cancer, and asbestosis. Proper asbestos abatement is essential to protect both human health and environmental safety. Asbestos-containing materials must be carefully handled and disposed of using specialized procedures to prevent further contamination and reduce the risk of exposure. Mesothelioma, a rare but aggressive cancer, is directly linked to asbestos exposure, with symptoms often not manifesting until decades later. Lung cancer and asbestosis are prevalent among individuals exposed to asbestos. Meticulous abatement procedures are essential to prevent exposure and mitigate the associated health risks. Proper asbestos abatement is vital for environmental protection. Improper handling of asbestos can contaminate soil, water sources, and ecosystems. Effective asbestos abatement contributes to regulatory compliance and legal obligations. Many countries have established regulations and guidelines governing the management and removal of asbestos to protect public health and the environment.  Proper asbestos abatement plays a crucial role in property management and maintenance. Failure to identify and address asbestos hazards during renovation or demolition projects can lead to costly delays, health hazards, and potential legal disputes. Investing in proper asbestos abatement can yield long-term economic benefits. While the initial costs of abatement may seem daunting, they pale compared to the potential expenses associated with asbestos-related illnesses, legal liabilities, and environmental remediation. Property owners can proactively address asbestos hazards and avoid costly litigation, property devaluation, and reputational damage. It helps to minimize the ecological impact of asbestos and ensure the sustainability of the environment for future generations.  Promoting asbestos awareness and implementing preventive measures can reduce the future burden on healthcare systems and taxpayers. The importance of proper asbestos abatement must be balanced. Effective abatement practices are essential for mitigating the risks associated with asbestos exposure, from safeguarding human health and safety to protecting the environment and ensuring regulatory compliance. Investing in thorough assessments, safe removal procedures, and proper disposal methods can minimize the health hazards, environmental impact, and legal liabilities associated with asbestos. Prioritizing proper asbestos abatement is a matter of compliance and a fundamental responsibility to safeguard lives and preserve the environment's integrity. ...Read more
Asbestos abatement involves identifying, removing, and safely disposing of materials that contain asbestos to eliminate the significant health risks associated with exposure. This process is especially important in older buildings, where asbestos was commonly used. Inhalation of asbestos fibers can lead to serious respiratory illnesses, such as asbestosis, lung cancer, and mesothelioma, which may take years to manifest. Effective asbestos abatement mitigates these immediate hazards while promoting long-term public health and safety. Abatement reduces the risk of these severe health conditions by removing asbestos from environments where people live, work, or spend significant time. If disturbed, asbestos fibers can become airborne, contaminating indoor air. It is hazardous because microscopic asbestos particles can be inhaled without immediate detection. Due to its known health hazards, many countries have stringent asbestos use and removal regulations. Compliance with these regulations through proper abatement ensures that property owners avoid hefty fines and legal issues while contributing to broader public health goals. Properties containing asbestos are often less desirable in the real estate market due to health risks and potential legal liabilities. Asbestos abatement can significantly enhance the value of a property by eliminating these risks. It is significant for older buildings undergoing renovations or those being prepared for sale. Abatement makes the property safer, more marketable, and potentially more profitable. Improper disposal of asbestos can lead to environmental contamination, affecting soil and water sources. Asbestos abatement involves safely removing and disposing of asbestos-containing materials, ensuring that these harmful substances do not pollute the environment.  For building occupants, knowing that their environment is free from asbestos can significantly improve their sense of safety and well-being. It is imperative in public and commercial buildings where occupant satisfaction and safety are paramount. The process often includes specific containment and disposal procedures that prevent the release of asbestos fibers into the air, soil, or water, protecting ecosystems and public health. Property owners are legally responsible for the presence of hazardous materials, including asbestos, within their buildings. Failure to address asbestos issues can lead to lawsuits, particularly if individuals suffer health problems due to exposure.  Conducting asbestos abatement can significantly reduce property owners' legal liability and litigation and settlement costs. Asbestos abatement is often a necessary step before any renovation or demolition project. It ensures that workers are not exposed to asbestos during the construction process. It also allows for the safe updating and modernization of buildings, contributing to urban renewal and development efforts. Abatement facilitates compliance with building codes and standards, making it an integral part of responsible construction management. Asbestos abatement offers numerous benefits, primarily centered around health and safety.  ...Read more